Adamawa Court Sentences Man To Death After Killing Church Member

By Paul Joseph

A High Court of Justice sitting in Ganye Judicial Division, Adamawa State, has sentenced a man, Bamaiyi Garrison, to death by hanging for the killing of a fellow church member, John Caleb.

Garrison, a resident of Wakka village in Mayo-Belwa Local Government Area of the state, was convicted of culpable homicide punishable by death following his arraignment before the court presided over by Justice Maxwell T. Pukuma.

The case stemmed from an incident that occurred on June 21, 2021, after a church service at the Lutheran Church of Christ in Nigeria (LCCN), Goromiyu, in Mayo-Belwa Local Government Area.

According to evidence presented before the court, Garrison had informed members of the church that Caleb allegedly stole a chicken belonging to one Miracle.

Days later, the convict visited Caleb at his residence to inquire why he had stopped attending church services.

However, an argument reportedly ensued after Caleb asked Garrison to leave his house. When Garrison refused, Caleb allegedly picked up a hoe and struck him.

Rather than retreat, Garrison reportedly wrestled the hoe from Caleb and struck him twice on the head.

Caleb was subsequently rushed to General Hospital, Zing, in neighbouring Taraba State, where a medical doctor examined him and certified him dead.

During the trial, the prosecution called three witnesses and tendered Garrison’s extra-judicial confessional statement, which was admitted in evidence without objection and marked as Exhibit M.

The prosecution’s case was further supported by the testimonies of the second prosecution witness and Garrison himself, who testified as the first defence witness.

Although the defendant raised the defences of accident and self-defence, the court held that neither defence could absolve him of criminal responsibility.

Delivering judgment, Justice Pukuma said the court had carefully evaluated the evidence and its probative value before arriving at the conclusion that the prosecution had established its case against the defendant.

The judge consequently found Garrison guilty of culpable homicide and sentenced him to death by hanging.