From Fashola on Channels TV to Umahi on Arise TV: The Need for More Explanatory Journalism

By Isaac Monehin

Seun Okinbaloye, anchor of Channels Television’s Politics Today, and Rufai Oseni of Arise Television are undoubtedly accomplished journalists. Their intellectual capacity, interviewing experience and ability to command an audience are hardly in doubt.

Both Channels and Arise Television have earned considerable recognition as Nigeria’s popular broadcast media organisations. However, there is an increasingly noticeable dimension to their political programming that deserves some reflection: the tendency to substitute confrontational interrogation and populist sentiment for the deeper analysis and public enlightenment that responsible journalism should promote.

This observation is not an argument against holding government accountable. Indeed, the media must question those in authority, interrogate public policies, expose failures and give voice to citizens whose economic circumstances have become increasingly difficult. But there is a fundamental difference between holding government accountable and conducting interviews in a manner that appears designed primarily to reinforce public anger.

The distinction is particularly important when discussing Nigeria’s economic reforms.
Nigeria is experiencing considerable economic difficulties. Inflation, high food prices, declining purchasing power, unemployment and the general cost-of-living crisis are real and cannot be dismissed with macroeconomic statistics. Millions of Nigerians are struggling, and government deserves to be challenged over the pace, sequencing and social consequences of its policies.

However, economic journalism must go beyond documenting hardship. It must explain why the hardship exists, what caused it, what alternative policy options are available, what each option will cost and what consequences Nigerians should expect from pursuing or abandoning particular reforms.

For instance, the removal of fuel subsidy, exchange-rate unification and monetary tightening are not isolated political decisions. They are interventions in a deeply distorted economic structure that had become increasingly expensive to sustain. Whether the Tinubu administration has implemented them optimally is a legitimate subject for debate. But responsible journalism should examine both the circumstances that necessitated these interventions and the consequences of alternative approaches.

Would a return to fuel subsidy necessarily make Nigerians better off? How would it be financed? What would be its implications for public debt, investment, foreign exchange and the fiscal sustainability of government? Equally, what concrete measures are being taken to ensure that the benefits of economic stabilisation translate into improved household welfare?

These are the questions that deepen public understanding. Simply amplifying public frustration does not. The November 17 interview with former Governor Babatunde Fashola on Channels TV by Seun Okinbaloye and the October 7th, 2025, interview of the Honourable Minister of Works, Engr. David Umahi, by Rufai Oseni of Arise TV on the issue of the Lagos-Calabar coastal road provide interesting reference points.

In the Channels interview, Fashola defended the administration’s economic reforms, acknowledged the hardship Nigerians are experiencing and argued that improvements in aggregate economic performance would eventually translate into household benefits.

He also discussed the need to assess alternative policy proposals before abandoning the present reform trajectory. These were arguments deserving rigorous interrogation. There would have been nothing wrong if Seun had challenged Fashola to provide evidence of measurable improvements and to explain the transmission mechanism between macroeconomic growth and household welfare.

In the Arise TV interview under reference, Rufai was overly combative, unnecessarily personal and, at certain moments, inconsistent with the temperament expected of a professional television journalist. Although his performance was journalistically legitimate, the execution was professionally questionable.

There should be a difference between probing an argument and appearing to prosecute the person making it. The former is journalism; the latter risks turning an interview into a contest of personalities and political positions.

Take, for instance, the issue of President Tinubu’s promise during the 2023 campaign to provide Nigerians with electricity in four years and that, should he fail, he should not be re-elected for a second term. Seun Okinbaloye’s decision to stop the recording before the President completed his statement, particularly when the omitted portion contained an important qualification, raises a legitimate question about editorial fairness and the integrity of the interview. But for the insistence of former Governor Fashola that the full tape be played, we would not have known the true story.

The President indeed qualified his statement with: “unless I give you adequate reasons why I couldn’t deliver.” This incident is an instance of questionable editorial judgement that risks undermining the credibility of political journalism. With the selective presentation of facts, there is a strong danger of predetermined conclusions.

The same concern applies to some of the morning programmes on Channels Television. Their discussions sometimes appear to place a greater premium on emotional reactions, political sparring and sensational exchanges than on systematic examination of public policy.

There is a troubling misconception gaining ground in Nigerian television journalism: that the more combative a journalist is, the more courageous and accountable the journalism becomes. This is a fundamental misunderstanding of the profession. Aggression is not the same as courage; confrontation is not necessarily accountability; and making a public official uncomfortable is not, in itself, evidence of effective journalism.

The real test of political journalism is not how effectively an interviewer exposes a guest to public ridicule or how successfully a presenter articulates popular anger. It is whether the interview extracts facts, tests arguments, exposes contradictions, examines alternatives and leaves the audience better informed than it was before.

Unfortunately, some of our prominent television presenters increasingly appear to approach political interviews as contests to be won rather than opportunities for public enlightenment. The interviewer’s personal position sometimes becomes so prominent that the subject being discussed takes second place. The result is often an emotionally charged exchange in which viewers are encouraged to take sides rather than equipped to understand the issues.

The concern with the interviewing styles of Seun Okinbaloye, Rufai Oseni and some other prominent television presenters is therefore not about their right to criticise the government. That right must remain sacrosanct. It is about the growing tendency to mistake adversarial presentation for analytical depth and emotional engagement for public enlightenment.

Government officials must be challenged, sometimes relentlessly. But they must be challenged with facts, informed arguments and intelligent follow-up questions. Equally, opposition politicians must face the same standards of scrutiny. No political position should enjoy immunity from serious interrogation.
The media must resist the temptation to become either the government’s public relations department or the opposition’s cheering squad. Its loyalty should be to facts, evidence and the public interest.

Another consequential electoral season is here. The media is already an arena for competing political narratives. Broadcasters must resist the temptation to become unwitting instruments of political mobilisation, whether for the government or the opposition.

The Nigerian public deserves more than television gladiators, dramatic exchanges and daily rehearsals of political grievances. It deserves journalists who can simplify complex economic issues without distorting them, challenge political authorities without grandstanding and interrogate opposition promises without prejudice.

Seun Okinbaloye and his colleagues at Channels Television have the platform, visibility and professional experience to contribute meaningfully to this national responsibility. The same goes for Rufai Oseni of Arise Television. Clearly, Dr. Reuben Abati has a lot of work (shall I say, mentoring?) to do here.
The central issue is to move from confrontational journalism to explanatory journalism; from emotional amplification to intellectual interrogation; and from merely reflecting public anger to helping the public understand the issues generating that anger.

Journalism should not merely tell Nigerians how angry they ought to be. It should help them understand why things are the way they are, what can realistically be done about them and how to hold those responsible to account.

That is the difference between journalism that merely entertains and journalism that educates, enlightens and builds a more informed society.

Isaac Monehin is an economist and public affairs analyst. He can be reached at monehinisaac@gmail.com (mailto:monehinisaac@gmail.com).


Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *